News and Updates

About Us

About Noble Reynolds Insurance


  C. R. Noble Insurance Agency originally operated in the 1960s in Orwell, Jefferson and Bristolville as Jack-McGowan-Noble Insurance and in Jefferson and Bristolville during much of the 1970s as Noble-Massengill Insurance.  When Connie Noble broke off to operate an agency of his own in 1981, C. R. Noble Insurance Agency was founded.  When he passed away in 1987, his daughter, Sherry Noble Leasure took over the operation of the agency, being joined in 1996 by her husband, Pete Leasure. 

The Reynolds Agency was founded by D. D. Reynolds in the 1930s in Middlefield.  The agency was owned and operated by the Reynolds family for many years, eventually being sold to Michaelean Pesek, who operated the agency until her retirement in 2007. 

Noble Reynolds Insurance was formed in 2007 when C. R. Noble Insurance Agency in Bristolville acquired The Reynolds Agency in Middlefield.  Each agency had a long history serving their respective communities; Noble Reynolds Insurance continues that legacy.  As one agency with two convenient locations, we are proud to serve Northeast Ohio, including the counties of Trumbull, Geauga, Ashtabula and Lake.  We are committed to building relationships with our many clients while offering practical insurance solutions.  As an Independent Agency, we have the ability to shop your insurance needs among many different companies to provide you with the coverage and price you are looking for.  Contact us today for a free, no obligation quote! 

What We Offer


Personal Insurance          

  • Homeowners
  • Auto
  • Life​
  • Farm 

Commercial Insurance     

  • Business       
  • Commercial     
  • Contractor ​      
  • Commercial Auto    
  • Surety Bonds 

Building Relationships


Here at Noble Reynolds Insurance Agency, we are dedicated to you and all your different insurance needs. Our most important win is making you a happy, life-long customer. 

Auto Policies 

As an independent agent, we combine different quotes that are provided by the most reasonable insurance rates that meets your personal or business needs. Feel free to give us a call today for your free quote. 


 There are a lot of different ways we can keep you and your house safe if anything might happen to you. From custom packages to a simple consult on what your options are, we've got all your home needs covered.